Sliding vs Swing Gates: Which is Best for Your HDB?

If you live in a BTO or an older HDB corridor unit, you know the struggle: Space is precious.

The area between your timber door and the metal gate is often tiny. When you open a traditional metal gate, it swings out, blocking the common corridor, hitting your neighbor’s shoe rack, or just making it awkward to carry groceries inside.

As homeowners look for smarter renovation solutions, the debate between the Classic Swing Gate and the modern Slide & Swing Gate has become a hot topic.

At Enforce, we believe your entrance should be secure and convenient. Here is a breakdown of which gate style suits your HDB lifestyle best.

1. The Classic Swing Gate (Mild Steel / Wrought Iron)

This is the standard gate you see in 90% of Singapore homes. It consists of two panels that swing outwards 180 degrees.

• The Pros:
  • Durability: With simple hinges and fewer moving parts, these gates are incredibly robust and last for decades.
  • Cost-Effective: It is generally the most affordable option.
  • Airflow: Standard bar designs allow maximum ventilation into your living room.
• The Cons:
  • The “Corridor Block”: When fully open, the wings block the pathway. If you live in a narrow corridor unit, this can be a nuisance for neighbors.
  • Dead Space: You cannot place a shoe rack or bench behind the gate because it needs the radius to swing open.

2. The “Slide & Swing” Gate (The Space Saver)

Often just called a “Sliding Gate” in the HDB context, this is a hybrid design that has exploded in popularity for BTOs. It works by allowing the panels to slide and fold onto one another, tucking neatly against the wall.

• The Pros:
  • Zero Radius: It doesn’t swing out. This is a game-changer for corner units or narrow corridors.
  • Partial Opening: You can slide open just one small section to collect a GrabFood delivery without opening the whole gate.
  • More Space: Because it doesn’t swing, you can place a larger shoe cabinet or a delivery parcel box right next to your door without obstruction.
• The Cons:
  • Maintenance: It relies on a track and roller system. Like any mechanical system, tracks can collect dust or rollers can wear out over time if not high quality.
  • Price: Due to the complex mechanism, these gates typically cost 30-50% more than a standard swing gate.

3. Which Should You Choose?

Choose the Swing Gate if:

• You are on a tight renovation budget.
• You have a recess area (bought space) in front of your flat, so swinging out doesn’t block anyone.
• You prefer a simple, heavy-duty “old school” feel.

Choose the Slide & Swing Gate if:

• You live in a corridor unit with heavy foot traffic.
• You want to maximize the space in your entryway for a nice shoe bench or plants.
• You prefer a modern, flush look.

Quality Matters More Than Style

Whether you choose to swing or slide, the most important factor is the quality of the metal and the installation. Cheap gates use thin steel that rusts quickly or tracks that jam after a year.

At Enforce, we prioritize precision engineering. We ensure that whatever mechanism you choose, it operates smoothly and provides the security your family needs.

Looking to upgrade your HDB gate? Contact us to view our latest designs and material options.